Extremely problematic and incredibly mismanaged - Avis employé Writer Inkitt

1,0
27 juin 2021
Recommande
Approbation du PDG
Perspective commerciale

Avantages

The majority of people who I worked with are smart, well-intentioned professionals. Unfortunately, they don't have any power, but I did meet some awesome people, who made the day to day fun and creative. I learnt a lot as a writer. Mostly about how to work with unreasonable people to unreasonable deadlines, but these are valuable lessons nonetheless. The office is dog friendly. I feel like there is a good story in here somewhere - the essay written below does not scratch the surface of the weirdness I encountered at this self-parodic organisation.

Inconvénients

I was excited to write raunchy pulp fiction for Galatea, but ended up feeling pressured into developing some deeply disturbing content. You see, being 'data-driven for Ali and his henchpeople meant that all Galatea projects were picked from their self-published platform Inkitt by an algorithm, with no system in place to check if the stories were appropriate for development. Inkitt is, in practice anyway, an erotic romance platform, consumed by people looking for erotica. Nothing wrong with any of that! The problem was that the stories our algorithm increasingly flagged with ‘best seller’ potential were objectively toxic - romanticising assault, abuse and paedophilia. Obviously, self-published writers can write what they like - but it felt extremely uncomfortable to be forced to develop this kind of work, which was then sold at a premium to a fairly young and impressionable audience. Writers tried to polish out the worst elements of such stories, but that put us at loggerheads with management - whose position was that the algorithm had picked this story for a reason and we must not question the algorithm. Writing romanticised stories of abuse to tight deadlines was, unsurprisingly, taking a toll on my mental health. I was also concerned that these stories could get the company (and the writers connected with it) in trouble - not to mention putting off plenty of potential customers. These issues were raised repeatedly - but despite management's constant demands for feedback nothing was done. Eventually, they said that ‘personal ethics’ was not a valid reason for rejecting a story. In April 2020 I was part of a group that was let go over zoom all hands, after weeks of Ali telling us that our sales had gone up since the pandemic. They made us an ‘alumni Slack’ that booted us off the main one - making it hard to even swap contacts with colleagues. They pressured us to sign ‘agreements’ that basically fired ourselves - putting us at risk of losing access to benefits. The ‘severance’ was just our notice period. Some people were just weeks off qualifying for state unemployment and lost out on a year's worth of support during a pandemic. The references that we were promised turned out to be a document talking about how Inkitt is the new Disney - with no mention of our role or personal achievements. The few who fought for proper severance were subjected to weeks of bullying phone calls from management. Truth be told, I don’t believe that they made us redundant because of the pandemic, even though that was the reason given. There were many options for furloughing staff during this period that other companies took up, and I can see that they have been hiring writers since. I believe they used this pandemic as an excuse to sweep the office clear of naysayers. The writers that were made redundant were mixed in seniority and experience but linked by the fact they voiced concerns about the content we were being asked to develop. From what I understand, management has doubled down in their uncritical subservience to the creepy algorithm since we left. The company is generally ridiculous. Their ‘we’re the next Disney thing’ is so embarrassing. All these companies have in common is a narcissistic founder and love of romanticising toxic relationships. Ali is a strange dude. Even when he’s being nice, the result is weirdly intrusive. He got us all enneagram tests but then forced us to share our results on our slack. He spent crazy money on fitness instructors but then awkwardly pressured everyone to be weighed in the office. After the zoom redundancies, he sent out copy-pasted ‘thank you’ messages to fired peoples and sent out frankly insulting enneagram affirmation cards. His priorities were all over the place. He bought a 3000 euro rug for the meeting room (and then banned red wine from the office ) but when the sound department asked for a recording mic he got them a 20 euro USB one. Desperately needed roles were left unfilled because he'd only accept the best of the best despite offering them very little. Meanwhile, he handed senior management roles to inexperienced friends and their friends and family, dooming the place to perpetual mismanagement. While I try to be empathetic that he's just spectacularly out of his depth, there were plenty of moments that revealed callousness. Loudly discussing (in the middle of an open-plan office) a potential candidate’s lack of ambition because she recently had children was just one uncomfortable moment that springs to mind. To those thinking of working for Inkitt (especially if you are relocating), please pay close attention to negative reviews, as management repeatedly pressures people to write good ones. They also put up fakes - I can see several reviews that look suspiciously HR-written have gone up since I left. I would also be extra careful of creative roles. Management treat the content team like easily replaceable garbage, and will 100% swap them for bots ​once the technology's halfway there. You are likely to be strung along by the exploitative test work and forced to write objectively terrible things to unrealistic deadlines. They don't care about your ideas/expertise and voicing concerns will likely lose you your job. To all the lovely people still stuck there - seriously consider legal insurance, and screenshot anything screwed up. Oh, and if you're a writer, maybe use a pen name - you don't want to be associated with these clowns down the line. To those thinking of investing in Inkitt, please consider that this is a digital media company that, at a time when the world was suddenly extremely reliant on digital media, could not imagine its content being profitable. From what I can tell, they are selling the algorithm - which is basic at best and creepy at worst. It just ain't worth it.

avatar
Réponse de Inkitt
4y
Hi there, Thank you for sharing all your feedback and thoughts. We are really sorry to hear about your negative experience at the company. We are always doing our best to take everyone’s input and wishes into consideration, and I want to reassure you that we will do our best to always become a better workplace. In which case, we’ve taken the time to review this feedback carefully to identify learning opportunities. We would also like to use this opportunity to share our perspective on a few of the points mentioned. Regarding the lay-offs; last year during the pandemic, many firms had to make team adjustments and we were regrettably no exception. We are sincerely sorry that you and the rest of our former colleagues were impacted. We acknowledge that, given the circumstances, the process was not ideal. Please remember that as we were all in lockdown, the difficult conversations had to happen via videoconferencing for the safety of all parties involved. A final point on this topic, Inkitt did take measures to ensure that the severances offered were generous. Responding to the point around the Enneagram test, another one of our company values is the pursuit of self development. Inkitt offers this personality test to employees as a perk and as means to develop a greater collegial and self awareness. While employees are indeed encouraged to take the test, no one is under any obligation to participate. In fact we have many examples of employees opting out; a decision which Inkitt has always respected. Lastly we want to state that we do have a clear content policy, which clearly spells out what type of content can and cannot be published. The policy categorically rejects all of the subject matters which the review claims that we publish. Further, we have an excellent Author Relations Manager whose job it is to ensure that our content policy is constantly upheld. No employee has ever been obligated to work on a project or subject that they dislike. Any time a creative team member has expressed a preference for not participating in a given project, Inkitt has always allowed the team member to work on a different one, with no questions asked. In fact, one of our core values is “Disagree and Commit”, which means team members are not only allowed, but rather encouraged to speak up constructively whenever they disagree with something. Inkitt champions independent thinkers and would never terminate an employee relationship for adherence to this value. As stated, we put self-development at the core of our operations here, therefore we appreciate hearing constructive feedback. One more time, we are truly sorry that your experience was a negative one. You can rest assured that we are continuously learning, and improving. The company we were a year ago is very different to the company we are today. We have learned, matured and improved. And the company we will be one year from now will be even better as we continue to learn, mature and improve. Sincerely, Your Inkitt Team

Découvrez plus d’avis sur Inkitt

5,0
31 mai 2026
Recommande
Approbation du PDG
Perspective commerciale

Avantages

- Being able to lead projects independently from A to Z and be trusted for it - Engaging daily with a creative and passionate team - Being part of exciting new projects in a fast-paced, fast-evolving industry - Steep learning curve, you'll be pushed out of your comfort zone and grow fast

Inconvénients

Inkitt is a fast-paced start-up with no set playbook. People who love structure and need to be managed and told what to do may find it challenging.

5,0
26 mai 2026
Recommande
Approbation du PDG
Perspective commerciale

Avantages

Inkitt is one of the few places that actually sits between tech and media in a way that works. A manuscript comes in, real reader behavior tells you whether the story has legs, and the team turns that signal into a career for the author. I think about reader retention and narrative pacing in the same conversation now, which I didn't before.

Inconvénients

The flip side is that the playbook doesn't fully exist yet. Some weeks you're inventing the process while running it. Energizing if you like ambiguity, exhausting if you don't. Worth being honest with yourself about which camp you're in before signing on.

Voir les avis par: Utile|Évaluation|Date|Tout